New York Rangers vs Columbus Blue Jackets Prediction: Best Bet for Saturday

NEW YORK RANGERS(6-3-0)
VS
COLUMBUS BLUE JACKETS(2-3-0)
SPREAD
New York Rangers -1.5
TOTAL
6.5
MONEYLINE
New York Rangers ML
Saturday (10/17) · 6:00 PM CT · NHLNationwide Arenaodds at time of writing
Nationwide Arena in Columbus, home of the Blue Jackets
Nationwide Arena in Columbus, home of the Blue Jackets. Photo: Eric, CC BY-SA 2.0, via Wikimedia Commons

New York Rangers (6-3-0) visits Columbus Blue Jackets (2-3-0) on Saturday. Our data-driven pick: New York Rangers -1.5.

The Matchup

Columbus has played only five games, and the small sample still tells a consistent story: the Blue Jackets score 3.00 goals per game but allow 4.20, a minus-1.20 differential, despite outshooting opponents 27.8 to 26.8. The Rangers, at 6-3-0, are built the opposite way: 3.11 scored, 2.33 allowed, plus-0.78, on low shot volume of 22.8 for and 24.8 against. New York wins by defending and finishing.

Columbus loses by defending badly. A team allowing 4.20 per game hosting a team allowing 2.33 does not require the visitor to play its best offensive game, only its normal defensive one.

Key Factors

The penalty kill gap is enormous. New York kills 92.9 percent of penalties. Columbus kills 61.1 percent, nearly the worst mark on the slate. The Rangers' 22.2 percent power play against that 61.1 percent kill is the most profitable matchup in the game on paper.

Columbus does own one real edge at the dot, 57.7 percent of faceoffs against New York's 54.6 percent, and both numbers are elite, so Columbus will start more shifts with the puck. The Rangers' 2.33 goals against says starting with the puck has not been enough against them. Columbus's 3.00 goals per game came with that 4.20 against, so the Jackets trade chances, and trading chances favors the team with the 92.9 percent kill.

Our Pick
New York Rangers -1.5+140

Columbus keeps trading chances at home, and that trade favors a team built to defend. We have New York winning by two. The Rangers kill 92.9 percent of penalties. Columbus kills just 61.1 percent. New York does not need its best offensive night here. It needs its usual defensive one, played against an opponent that gives goals back. Take New York minus-1.5 at plus-140.

Final Result
New York Rangers 0, Columbus Blue Jackets 1
Our pick New York Rangers -1.5 lost.

Game Information

DateSaturday (10/17)
Start Time6:00 PM CT
How to WatchNHL
VenueNationwide Arena
SpreadNew York Rangers -1.5
Total6.5
MoneylineNew York Rangers ML

Player Props for This Game

1 prop
  • Alexis Lafreniere GoalsOver 0.5 +175
See the full prop card for this game, with short analysis, on the NHL props page →

Every pick is published with its line before the game. Odds via consensus sportsbooks at time of writing and move constantly. Must be 21+. If gambling is a problem, call or text 1-800-GAMBLER.