New York Islanders vs Toronto Maple Leafs Prediction: Best Bet for Saturday

NEW YORK ISLANDERS(3-3-1)
VS
TORONTO MAPLE LEAFS(3-3-2)
TOTAL
6.5
MONEYLINE
New York Islanders ML
Saturday (10/17) · 6:00 PM CT · NHLScotiabank Arenaodds at time of writing
Scotiabank Arena in Toronto, home of the Maple Leafs
Scotiabank Arena in Toronto, home of the Maple Leafs. Photo: Paperfire, CC BY-SA 4.0, via Wikimedia Commons

New York Islanders (3-3-1) visits Toronto Maple Leafs (3-3-2) on Saturday. Our data-driven pick: New York Islanders ML.

The Matchup

Toronto at Scotiabank Arena headlines the 6:00 PM CT wave, and the Maple Leafs bring the bigger offense, 3.50 goals per game against the Islanders' 2.86. The problem is everything after Toronto scores. The Leafs allow 3.38 goals per game for a plus-0.12 differential, while the Islanders allow only 2.29 for a plus-0.57 differential built on structure rather than firepower.

New York is 3-3-1, Toronto 3-3-2, and the records match the profiles: Toronto plays entertaining, loose games that stay close, and the Islanders play tight games that stay close. When two close-game teams meet, the one allowing 1.09 fewer goals a night is usually mispriced as the road underdog.

Key Factors

Toronto's special teams are the biggest obstacle to this pick: a 29.6 percent power play paired with a remarkable 96.2 percent penalty kill. If the Leafs get power plays, the Islanders' 85.2 percent kill will be tested by the best unit in this game, and New York's own 18.2 percent power play is unlikely to score on a 96.2 percent kill.

Even-strength defense is where the Islanders win the argument anyway: 2.29 goals against on 26.0 shots allowed, against a Toronto team allowing 30.5 shots and 3.38 goals. The Islanders win 53.6 percent of faceoffs to Toronto's 52.4 percent, a small edge that suits a road team trying to slow the game down and shorten it.

Our Pick
New York Islanders ML+114

The Islanders are on the road in Toronto, where the home team carries the higher ceiling. We have the Islanders by 0.45 goals, a small edge built on structure, not scoring. The Islanders allow 2.29 goals per game against 3.38 for Toronto. Toronto can swing a tight game quickly, but its leakage keeps the visitors in it. Take the Islanders on the moneyline at plus-114.

Final Result
New York Islanders 4, Toronto Maple Leafs 1
Our pick New York Islanders ML won.

Game Information

DateSaturday (10/17)
Start Time6:00 PM CT
How to WatchNHL
VenueScotiabank Arena
Total6.5
MoneylineNew York Islanders ML

Player Props for This Game

2 props
  • Auston Matthews GoalsOver 0.5 +129
  • Matthew Schaefer AssistsOver 0.5 -114
See all 2 prop cards for this game, with short analysis, on the NHL props page →

Every pick is published with its line before the game. Odds via consensus sportsbooks at time of writing and move constantly. Must be 21+. If gambling is a problem, call or text 1-800-GAMBLER.